Trudeau’s reaction to Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s report provokes both hope and skepticism

The residential school system which was imposed upon generations of Indigenous people across so-called “Canada” is a permanent stain upon the history of this land.

The full extent of the horrors suffered by the children forced into these brutal institutions was for decades denied, then downplayed, then shrugged off as ancient history.

Former Prime Minister Stephen Harper did his best to put an end to discussion of the matter by offering a formal governmental apology, an apology that was clearly shown to be hollow when his government refused to cooperate with the survivor-funded Truth and Reconciliation Commission when it embarked on a systemic inquiry of residential schools some six years ago.

The TRC today released the final volume of its report on the residential school system. You may recall that the summary of their report, issued with 94 recommendations, was released with great fanfare back in June, on the eve of a federal election, and, in a pathetic commentary on white fragility, managed to make waves for its use of the term “cultural genocide” to describe the practice of forcibly removing Indigenous children from their parents, punishing them for speaking their languages, teaching them their customs were barbaric and savage, and employing extreme physical and sexual violence against them in an effort to make them conform.

One other moment from that event which sticks out in my memory is when TRC Chair Justice Murray Sinclair called for a national inquiry into murdered and missing Indigenous women, and the whole room stood and applauded except for Aboriginal Affairs Minister Bernard Valcourt, whom Thomas Mulciar side-eyed the fuck out of.

The change in tone from the Conservatives at the release of the report’s summary to the Liberals at the release of the full report is night and day. Here’s what Prime Minister Trudeau had to say today:

But here’s the thing: at this point, the difference is only one of tone, and that needs to be pointed out, again and again, relentlessly, because saying nice and comforting and agreeable things is what politicians are best at, and what ultimately matters least. Harper was willing to say the nice and comforting and agreeable things when he apologized for the residential school system, and he had no compunctions about thereafter decimating funding for Indigenous people, refusing to consult First Nations on major resource extraction projects which affected them, refusing to meet hunger-striking Attawapiskat Chief Theresa Spence, and enacting policies which made it much more difficult for Indigenous people to vote.

Similarly, the Liberal Party doesn’t exactly have a sparkling history when it comes to Indigenous issues, including under the current Prime Minister’s father and his then-Indian Affairs Minister (and future PM) Jean Chretien. As Cree writer Harold Cardinal put it back in his 1969 book “The Unjust Society”:

In spite of all government attempts to convince Indians to accept the white paper, their efforts will fail, because Indians understand that the path outlined by the Department of Indian Affairs through its mouthpiece, the Honourable Mr. Chrétien, leads directly to cultural genocide. We will not walk this path.

Note that almost fifty years later, we’re still arguing about whether the federal government’s treatment of First Nations is genocidal. (On the flip side, the same year that Pierre Trudeau released his now-infamous White Paper, the last residential school in Canada was closed.)

Today, a new Trudeau government faces new distinct challenges in its relations with First Nations – chief among these the tensions between respecting treaty rights and allowing the unrestrained extraction of natural resources. On this particular subject, so far JT has demonstrated a difference in tone and not much else.

And of course, this “do-the-right-thing” vs “but-profits!” dilemma cuts right to the heart of the issue. From the TRC’s summary:

“These measures were part of a coherent policy to eliminate Aboriginal people as distinct peoples and to assimilate them into the Canadian mainstream against their will,” says the 381-page summary of its final report released Tuesday [June 2 2015] in Ottawa.

The Canadian government pursued this policy of cultural genocide because it wished to divest itself of its legal and financial obligations to Aboriginal people and gain control over their land and resources,” says the report. [my bold]

So forgive me for not seeing the Prime Minister’s sincere-seeming expression of a desire to see an accurate history of Aboriginal suffering and oppression taught in schools as proof positive of a radical turning point in nation-to-nation relations. The raison d’être of colonization has been and continues to be dispossession of land and resources for profit.

Words are cheap. Harper’s apology showed us all that. It’s the follow-through that really matters. Right now, Justin Trudeau is saying all the right things. But until we see what he actually does, I’m going to remain cautiously skeptical.


Off-Topic Tuesday is when I write about whatever the hell I want to. You can reach me at matt@thealfalfafield.com or leave a comment below.

Got Something To Say:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

Copyright © 2018. Powered by WordPress & Romangie Theme.